A nonprofit website brings in donations when giving is easy to find, the impact of a gift is specific, and the donation form is short and works on a phone. Most sites tell the story well but bury the Donate button or send people to a clunky outside page. A few focused changes usually help more than a full redesign.
Why good causes still lose online donations
Supporters often arrive ready to give. They saw a post, heard about you at an event or got a letter. Then the site gets in the way.
Common problems we see:
- The Donate button is small, gray or hidden in a menu.
- The form asks for a dozen fields, including some that are not needed.
- The donation page opens a different-looking site, and people wonder if it is safe.
- There is no monthly giving option.
- The form is hard to use on a phone.
Each one costs gifts. None of them is hard to fix.
Make giving obvious on every page
Put a Donate button in the header of every page, in a color that stands out from the rest of the site. On mobile it should stay visible without opening the menu.
Add a clear giving section to the home page, near the top. Repeat the call to give at the end of program pages and stories, where readers feel most connected to the work.
Keep the button wording plain. “Donate” or “Give now” works. Clever wording slows people down.
Show exactly what a gift does
Donors want to know where the money goes. “Support our mission” is vague. A specific line is easier to act on.
Tie suggested amounts to real outcomes from your own budget. For example, if $50 covers a week of groceries for one family in your program, say so next to the $50 option. Only use numbers you can stand behind.
Use real photos of your people and programs, with permission. Short stories, a few sentences each, work better than long reports. Grant makers look for the same clarity, which we cover in grants want a professional online presence.
Build a donation form people finish
The form is where most gifts are won or lost. Treat every field as a cost.
A good donation form includes:
- Three or four suggested amounts plus an “other” box.
- A one-time or monthly choice, with monthly easy to pick.
- Name, email and payment details. Ask for an address only if you need it for receipts or mail.
- An optional “give in honor of” field.
- Apple Pay or Google Pay where your processor supports it.
- A clear thank-you page and an automatic email receipt.
Keep the form on your own site, styled like the rest of it, so donors trust it. A secure payment processor handles the card data in the background. Adding a payment or donation form to a site we build is a $550 add-on.
Turn first gifts into ongoing support
A first gift is the start of a relationship. Your site and email can handle much of the follow-up.
Send a thank-you message right away, then a short update a few weeks later showing what the gift did. Invite donors to an event or a volunteer day. If you host events, online sign-ups make that easier, as covered in event registration without the headache.
Monthly donors deserve special care. A simple welcome note, a yearly giving summary and an easy way to update their card keep them giving.
Make the year-end receipt easy too. Donors who get a clean summary of their gifts in January, without having to ask, remember who made tax time simple.
Earn trust before the ask
People give to organizations they believe are real, careful and still active. Your nonprofit website can show that in a few quiet ways.
- An About page with your board, staff and a short history.
- Your mission in one or two plain sentences, near the top of the home page.
- Recent dates on news, events and stories, so the site does not look abandoned.
- A clear note on how donations are used, and a link to financial reports if you publish them.
- A real address and phone number, not just a contact form.
- A secure site, so the browser shows the padlock on every page.
None of these ask for money directly. They answer the questions donors have before they reach for a card. A visitor who trusts you is far more likely to finish the form.
Speed matters here as well. A slow, heavy home page on a phone loses visitors before they ever see your story. Keep photos compressed and the page focused.
What a nonprofit website costs
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Design package, up to 5 pages | $2,950 |
| Design package, up to 12 pages | $5,950 |
| Payment or donation form | $550 |
| Spanish version | $1,650 |
| WCAG accessibility review | $750 |
| Website care plan | from $199 per month |
Nonprofits get 10% off builds. A small organization with a five-page site and a donation form would pay $3,500 before the discount, or $3,150 after it. Most sites take 3 to 6 weeks. See website design for what is included, and website care plans if you want us to keep the site updated for you.
Questions people ask
Should we use a donation platform or a form on our own site?
A platform is quick to set up, but it can send donors to a page that looks different and may carry extra fees. A form on your own site keeps your branding and builds trust. Either way, the payment processor handles the card data securely.
Is a monthly giving option worth adding?
Usually, yes. Monthly gifts give you steadier income to plan around. Make it a simple toggle on the main form instead of a separate page.
Does our nonprofit website need to be accessible?
It should be. Accessible sites work for donors with disabilities and are easier for everyone to use. Our WCAG accessibility review is $750 and checks contrast, headings, forms and keyboard use.
How often should we update the site?
Post a short program update or story at least monthly. Fresh, real content shows donors and grant makers you are active. A care plan can handle the updates if staff time is tight.
Not sure what is holding your donation page back? Request a free website review and we will show you the first fixes.